Adult Mosquito Control Products

Adulticiding is the final component of Integrated Mosquito Management. Although every effort is taken to eliminate mosquito larvae before they become adults, various factors make it impossible to eliminate every mosquito. Therefore, adult mosquitoes emerge from breeding sites or migrate into Cass County in search of a meal or a mate. 

Mosquitoes in the adult stage can be controlled while resting or flying. Our decision to initiate an application to control adult mosquitoes is based on surveillance results, inspections by field aides, sweep counts, and nuisance mosquito calls. 

Truck Fogging Image

 

 

Cass County uses a number of synthetic pyrethroids to control adult mosquitoes. Pyrethroids are synthetic chemical insecticides that act in a similar manner to pyrethrins, which are derived from chrysanthemum flowers. Check out the EPA website on these products. Pyrethroids are widely used for controlling various organisms including head lice. Permethrin, bifenthrin, and etofenprox, are synthetic pyrethroids commonly used in mosquito control programs to kill adult mosquitoes.

  • Permethrin has been registered by EPA since 1977. It is currently registered and sold in a number of products such as household insect foggers; ant and other insect sprays for the home; tick and flea sprays; flea dips & sprays; collars for cats and dogs; termite treatments; agricultural and livestock products; for the treatment of head and body lice; and mosquito abatement products. Cass County utilizes permethrin adulticides in all ULV applications including aerial applications.

Cass County has 31 truck mounted foggers that are calibrated to apply ultra low volume(ULV) spray of pyrethroid insecticides. Our ULV trucks put out droplets around 20 microns in diameter or 0.0008 inches across (about the width of a living cell). These droplets are in the air for about half an hour and travel up to 300ft. Cass County Vector Control currently uses an application rate of approximately 0.0035 lbs per acre of permethrin, or about 0.4 grams of active ingredient per "average" household yard- this is the approximate weight of roughly 10 standard size staples

Compare that to a single can of common household pesticide used in backyards for control of mosquitoes and flying insects; each contains about 1.7 grams of permethrin and other similar active pesticides - about what a Vector Control truck would put out over an acre of land. In contrast, application rates for certain agricultural products such as apples can be up to 0.4 lbs of permethrin per acre of crop (181 grams per acre). 

Another way to think about permethrin mosquito spraying is to look at the dose applied to a single square foot of area. During an aerial application the rate of product is 0.007 lbs/acre. The dose per square foot is equal to 0.073 milligrams of product. For comparison; a popular head lice treatment contains 280 mg of permethrin per dose. Assuming an 8 inch diameter skull is a perfect sphere- the dosage of pesticide is 5,000x larger on the treated head than what is present after an aerial application for control of mosquitoes over the same area. If you follow the recommended treatment and require a second dose- the total amount on the skull is 10,000x more than aerial spraying.

Looking at one final example in "real life" terms, the mass of pesticide sprayed on the area the approximate size of a football field is equal to a standard coffee size or "small" packet of white sugar including the paper. the weight of 3 dollars bills is similar to the amount of product sprayed over a football field.

For an average sized household, (About 1/4 of a football field) the total weight or mass of the pesticide applied is less than the weight of 20 standard staples, or about the mass of 1/4 of a US penny coin.

From a Toxicity and Risk Perspective:

A panel of international experts convened by The World Health Organization and The United Nations published a 1989 report concluding that "There are no indications that permethrin, when used as recommended, will have an adverse effect on human beings". The report further describes studies of permethrin toxicity in mammals such as rats, guinea pigs, and dogs where no observed effect was seen when animals were directly feed up to 100 milligram of permethrin per kilogram of body weight per day in long term studies. One study that was acknowledged in the report showed no observable effects of permethrin dosages at a scale of a 30 pound dog receiving 1.5 grams or permethrin daily over three months of trial. In order to ingest that 1.5 gram nontoxic dose of pesticide, one would have to consume all the permethrin sprayed out by a ULV sprayer over an area 3/4 the size of a football field or about 40,000 square feet every day. Studies in rats suggest that a lethal dose of permethrin is almost six times the amount studied or approximately the total of material sprayed over a quarter of million square feet. Bare in mind that an acute overdose that could result in death of over counter pain relievers such as aspirin or acetaminophen is about 150 milligrams per kilogram or a dose of approximately 7.5 grams for an adult human. 

Furthermore, the World Health Organization lists an acceptable daily intake (ADI) of permethrin up to 0.05mg permethrin / kg of human body mass. For the average North American weighing 80kg (175 lbs) that is an ADI of 4 mg. ADI is calculated by using a 100 fold safety factor compared to the level determined by WHO as "No observed adverse effect level" or NOAEL. Table 4 Pg 47

Conspiracy theories and internet fear mongering greatly exaggerate the minimal - nearly non-existent risks of using adult control products via truck ULV treatments or aerial mosquito treatments. The science and use of these products is sound. The US Centers for Disease Control (CDC) endorses and encourages active mosquito control programs and furthermore adult mosquito control via aircraft.  Misconceptions and fear are a common side effect of ignorance of facts; facts that are built upon decades of empirical scientific study by some of the best PhD's, medical doctors, epidemiologists, and professional mosquito control programs. If other "solutions" were possible- use of alternatives would be wide spread and without a doubt widely publicized. Any support of crazy ideologies about bats or dragonflies or whatever nonsense is purely anecdotal and frankly impressively uninformed and lazy. Dr. Robert Peterson PhD of Montana State University expertly summarizes these facts, stating: 

"Results from our risk assessment and the current weight of scientific evidence (Currier et al. 2005Karpati et al. 2004NYCDOH 2001O’Sullivan et al. 2005U.S. EPA 2000c2005a2005b2005c) indicate that human-health risks from residential exposure to mosquito adulticides are very low and are not likely to exceed levels of concern. Further, by virtually any current human-health measure, the risks from infection by WNV exceed the risks from exposure to mosquito insecticides. Therefore, perceptions that human-health risks from the insecticides used to control adult mosquitoes are greater than the risks from WNV currently cannot be supported by current scientific evidence. Our results, and the results from other studies, should be used by the U.S. EPA, public health officials, and the general public to make better-informed decisions about risk–risk tradeoffs."

 

Lethal Dosages of Common Drugs and Substances **

Product or Chemical

LD50

Subject Observed

Sucrose Sugar 30,000 mg/kg rat
Citric Acid 12,000 mg/kg rat
Ethanol(aka alcohol) 5628 mg/kg rat
Permethrin (dermal) 2020 mg/kg rabbit
DEET 1793 mg/kg rat
Sodium lauryl sulfate (oral)  1288 mg/kg rate
Ibuprofen 1255 mg/kg mice
Permethrin (oral) 1250 mg/kg rat
Albuterol(Sambutamol) 1100 mg/kg mice
Ipratropium  1001mg/kg mice
Simethicone 900mg/kg dog
Salicylic Acid 891 mg/kg rat
Diphenhydramine 500 mg/kg rat
Warfarin 374mg/kg mice
Acetaminophen 338-1944 mg/kg mice-rat
Progesterone  (intraperitoneal) 327 mg/kg rat
Lidocaine 214-459 mg/kg rat
Caffeine 127 mg/kg mice
Dextromethorphan 112-201 mg/kg mice
Nicotine 24-50 mg/kg mice-rat
Vitamin D 10 mg/kg rat
Warfarin  3 mg/kg dog
Morphine 1.5-3.5 mg/kg human
Botox 0.00001 mg/kg rat
*note: 1 acre(43,560 sq ft) treatment of permethrin is 3175 milligrams (0.007 lbs) or less
 **LD50's from www.DrugBank,ca  and is supported by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research

 

Nonetheless it is always advisable to practice good hygiene. Wash your hands prior to eating food, smoking, chewing gum, removing contact lenses, before and after using the restroom, and other times which ingesting environmental contaminates can be possible. If you do come in contact with an application of any pesticide for mosquito control; simply remove yourself from the area and wash with clean water. Clothing can be left out in sunlight where the permethrin will break down from ultra violet light exposure and then washed. Wash dirt and environmental contaminates off garden and store bought fruits and vegetable with clean water to remove residues. Wash you hands and arms after applying flea dips to your pets or bathing them with flea and tick shampoo; remove soiled towels and air dry in sunlight before washing. Read all precautionary statements on lice, flea, and tick treatments. And at home always keep all potentially hazardous materials away from children and pets as 75% of all poisoning is from accidental ingestion.

 

To learn how to learn the steps to controlling adult mosquitoes around your property click here.

 

Cass County's current adult mosquito control material inventory:

 

Trade Name
Aqualuer 20-20 Label MSDS
Wisdom TC Flowable Label MSDS
Zenivex E4 Label MSDS
Pursuit 4-4 Label MSDS
PermX 4-4 Label MSDS

 

 

For more information:

 

http://www.epa.gov/pesticides/health/mosquitoes/pyrethroids4mosquitoes.htm#pyrethroids

http://npic.orst.edu/pest/mosquito/mosqcides.html

https://www.drugbank.ca